The Poacher Who Went Legal
Memories of Whitby, the River Esk and the poaching culture of the 1970’s and 80’s
Some names and biographical details have been changed to protect the identities of those involved. These stories combine my own memories, conversations with those involved and folklore passed down through Whitby’s fishing community, most people mentioned are now dead.
There was a time in Whitby when poaching was almost a way of life. Back in the 1980s, particularly during the autumn months when salmon and sea trout were returning to the River Esk, illegal nets were seemingly everywhere. Around practically every headland, behind boats in the harbour, along the piers and up the tidal river, there were men trying to catch a few fish. Some did it for the money, others for the excitement, and a few appeared to do it because they simply couldn’t help themselves.
I knew many of those men, but one in particular stands out. For the purposes of this story, I’ll call him Jack, a friend going back many years and one of Whitby’s most colourful characters. He was a huge man, a gentle giant who wouldn’t hurt a fly, with a wonderful sense of humour and an easygoing personality that made him almost impossible to dislike. People simply loved him, and I was fortunate enough to share many adventures with him over the years.
Jack was an extraordinarily knowledgeable fisherman, but his greatest passion was undoubtedly the River Esk. He knew where salmon would lie, when they would move, how the tides and weather influenced their movements and how to navigate the riverbanks in almost complete darkness. It was knowledge that few people could ever hope to acquire without spending an enormous proportion of their lives beside the river. Jack practically lived and breathed the Esk, and I doubt I have ever met another man who understood it quite so intimately.
One particularly notorious method of poaching was known as snatching. It involved deliberately foul-hooking salmon or sea trout rather than catching them through conventional angling, and it was both illegal and incredibly cruel. Yet, for all its brutality, there was considerable skill involved in judging the movements of fish beneath the water and timing a cast while avoiding the lines of other poachers. Jack was remarkably good at it, as he was at almost everything involving the capture of fish.
As a teenager, I would regularly ride my old racing bike to Ruswarp on autumn weekends simply to watch the snatchers. Sometimes there would be ten men competing for position along the banks of the tidal Esk, watching for the tiniest ripple that might betray a salmon or sea trout moving upstream. Huge fish were occasionally landed, and the whole spectacle was strangely addictive to a youngster who loved fishing. This wasn’t something happening under the cover of darkness, either; much of it took place in broad daylight, seemingly without a care in the world.
I even tried my hand at snatching when I was about thirteen, although my efforts were rather less impressive than those of the experienced poachers. I seemed to spend more time tangling everybody else’s lines than doing anything remotely resembling fishing. Apparently, I was something of a nuisance, and I certainly showed little aptitude for joining their ranks. My career as a salmon poacher was never going to amount to very much.
My own involvement in poaching was small and short-lived, partly because I was absolutely terrified of the law. The prospect of getting caught was usually enough to put me off before I’d even started, and eventually legitimate angling, particularly my beloved winter cod fishing, became my own obsession. Jack, on the other hand, was made of rather different stuff. To him, the excitement of catching fish, whatever the method, was almost irresistible.
I remember one adventure when I was about fourteen and a friend and I persuaded my dad to drive us down to Whitby Scar. Poor Dad hadn’t fully appreciated what his two young passengers had in mind, and things took a rather unexpected turn when a fisheries bailiff appeared. The next thing I remember was the pair of us hurtling back towards the car, shouting at Dad to drive. Bill was not best pleased to discover that he’d apparently become the getaway driver for two teenage idiots.
Fishing dominated our childhoods, although thankfully much of it was perfectly legal. We fished with longlines, spent endless hours around the harbour and explored the coast looking for opportunities to catch something. On hot summer days we would swim in the Esk, particularly at the Corner Pool near Sleights, where a rope swing would launch us out over the water. The river and the sea were our playgrounds, and fishing was as much a part of growing up as anything else.
But poaching was everywhere. I remember watching a well-known local character rowing across Whitby Harbour in broad daylight, setting an illegal net as confidently as any licensed fisherman might work his gear. On other occasions, I saw nets being carried across the Swing Bridge, seemingly without attracting a second glance. Whitby was a quieter town back then, particularly in autumn, and much of the population seemed content to mind its own business.
The Witch Hole, the gap between Whitby’s Inner and Outer East Piers, was another notorious spot for illegal netting. I remember one extraordinary fish that must have weighed more than twenty-five pounds, so enormous that its tail dragged along the ground as it was carried away. It was the sort of fish that would be remembered for years, although few people stopped to consider what its removal might mean for the river. Back then, there always seemed to be another tide, another run of fish and another opportunity.
Other nights took us towards Sandsend, with its rocky scars and the sound of the sea washing over the shore. I remember retreating to the fishermen’s shelter on Khyber Pass and watching the sunrise through those enormous glass windows, while the town slowly came back to life. Occasionally, we’d find a couple of Whitby’s more colourful characters asleep in the council deckchairs, including two gentlemen known locally as Rocking Harry and Big John. They had apparently discovered that the shelter provided somewhere reasonably comfortable to catch forty winks.

Rocking Harry And Big John asleep in The fishermen’s shelter on Khyber Pass 1988. Ai Interpretation
And Jack loved all kinds of fishing, not simply poaching. We spent days jigging for cod aboard friends’ boats, sometimes catching enormous quantities of fish, and his enthusiasm was infectious. On one particularly memorable occasion in 1986, after leaving Laughtons at around two in the morning, we somehow found ourselves heading to sea in his boat to haul gill nets off Sandsend. We’d had far too much to drink, and although I remember the remarkable sight of enormous cod appearing at the surface, I look back now and wonder how on earth we survived such stupidity.
Of course, wherever there were poachers, there were fisheries bailiffs, and over the years an extraordinary game of cat and mouse developed between them. Jack would tell me stories of nighttime pursuits along the river, disappearing into the darkness and occasionally finding imaginative ways to frustrate those trying to catch him. He claimed that one favourite trick among some of the lads was to let down the tyres on the bailiffs’ vehicles, making a speedy pursuit rather difficult. It was hardly sporting behaviour, but there was a mischievousness to many of those encounters that Jack found irresistible.
The bailiffs had a boat of their own, which they used to patrol the river and search for illegal nets. I remember hearing how they would drag a large grapple through the water, hoping to snag nets that had been secured beneath the surface. The boat was apparently kept in the police compound behind Whitby’s library, which brings me to one of the more extraordinary pieces of local poaching folklore. According to a story that circulated around town, somebody supposedly crept into the compound one night and drilled holes in the bailiffs’ boat, presumably hoping to put an end to their river patrols.
Whether that particular tale happened exactly as told, I honestly couldn’t say, and I certainly wouldn’t want to identify anyone on the strength of a story passed around Whitby pubs. But it gives some idea of the lengths to which poachers were reputedly prepared to go in their efforts to outwit the authorities. There were plenty of such stories in those days, some undoubtedly exaggerated, others perhaps containing more than a grain of truth. The line between local folklore and actual events could sometimes be remarkably difficult to establish.
A few years ago, I had a fascinating conversation with an elderly fisheries bailiff who remembered those days well. He spoke about the Whitby lads with surprising affection, describing them as lovable rogues who, in his experience, had never personally threatened him. According to his recollections, things became considerably more unpleasant when certain visiting poachers from Teesside began operating in the area. He remembered threats, damaged vehicles and even incidents involving baseball bats, a world away from the relatively good-natured encounters he associated with the local lads.
The bailiff remembered Jack particularly fondly. They had known one another for years, occasionally chatting quite amicably about the river and its fish despite standing on opposite sides of the law. He recalled that Jack had faced repeated prosecutions, yet always seemed drawn back to the river. Poaching had become something approaching an addiction, a compulsion that neither warnings nor court appearances seemed able to break.
Eventually, according to the bailiff, he decided that another confrontation on the riverbank was unlikely to achieve very much. Instead, he visited Jack’s home and spoke with his wife, explaining that continued offending could eventually result in imprisonment. There was now a young family to consider, and the consequences were no longer Jack’s alone. Perhaps it was the thought of his children and the possibility of losing his freedom that finally persuaded him to give up the nets, although only Jack could ever have told us for certain.
Another of Jack’s favourite stories concerned the arrival of night-vision binoculars. For generations the poachers had relied on darkness, combined with their intimate knowledge of the river, to avoid detection. Jack recalled hiding along the Esk one night when a bailiff, apparently aware of exactly where he was, called him over and offered him a look through a pair of binoculars.
“Look through there, Jack,” the bailiff told him.
Jack looked, and apparently gasped at what he could see. The bailiff explained that they could now see what the poachers were doing even in almost complete darkness. Jack told me he realised that the advantage he had enjoyed for so many years was disappearing. Technology was changing the old game, and the riverbanks would never be quite the same again.
And they certainly aren’t the same today. I still walk the very same headlands, piers and stretches of the Esk that I knew during the 1980s, and the transformation is remarkable. Where illegal nets were once commonplace, I now see none, and the groups of snatchers who once gathered along the tidal river have vanished. I was discussing this very subject with fisheries officers only recently, reflecting on how an activity that was once so widespread has virtually disappeared from the places I know.
It’s worth remembering that poaching wasn’t restricted to a handful of men working the river. In those days, illegal nets could be found along stretches of coast extending many miles north and south of Whitby, sometimes in places where you would scarcely expect anybody to be fishing. I remember a time when it seemed you could hardly find a headland without somebody having a net in the tide. Today, walking those same places, it is difficult to imagine quite how widespread it once was.
But there’s an uncomfortable question that comes with those memories. How much damage did all that poaching do to the Esk’s salmon and sea trout? We know that migratory fish face many pressures, including pollution, agricultural runoff, climate change and the difficulties of surviving at sea. Yet I find it impossible to believe that the relentless removal of fish before they had the opportunity to spawn did not also take its toll.
There is a terrible irony in the fact that some of the men who understood the river better than anybody were also among those exploiting it most heavily. Jack knew more about the Esk than almost any man I have ever met, and his knowledge was something I genuinely admired. But knowing how to catch a fish and understanding the consequences of removing it are two very different things. Perhaps that’s something we only truly appreciate when we get older and begin to look back.
I want to make something absolutely clear. These stories are told with affection for the characters involved, but they are certainly not intended to glorify poaching. Looking back now, with a greater understanding of the pressures facing our migratory fish, I find much of what happened difficult to justify. It was a different time, with different attitudes, but that doesn’t make everything we did or witnessed right.
We cannot know precisely how much damage was caused by the wholesale removal of salmon and sea trout, but I firmly believe it contributed to the decline of fish in the Esk. We loved that river, or at least we believed we did, but loving something and knowing how to protect it are not necessarily the same thing. We understood where the fish were, when they would arrive and how to catch them. What we failed to fully appreciate was how easily we might lose them.
I hope that one day the Esk will once again support healthy numbers of salmon and sea trout. I hope future generations will have the opportunity to experience the excitement of seeing these magnificent fish returning to their river, rather than simply reading stories about the days when they were abundant. We cannot change what happened forty years ago, but we can learn from it. Whatever the future holds for the River Esk, we must never allow that level of exploitation to happen again.
And perhaps that’s why these memories are worth recording. They describe a part of Whitby’s history that has largely disappeared, along with many of the characters who made it what it was. It wasn’t always a pretty business, and I wouldn’t pretend otherwise, but there was humour, friendship, extraordinary local knowledge and a whole culture that younger generations may struggle to imagine. We can remember those people fondly without pretending that everything they did was right.
Sadly, Jack never had the opportunity to grow old. An accident took him far too young, leaving behind a family, many friends and a lifetime of stories that can still raise a smile. We had many adventures together, and although we didn’t always see eye to eye, I remember him with enormous affection. There are times when I wish we could sit down together and talk fishing just one more time.
Which brings me to perhaps my favourite memory of him.
By this stage in my life, I’d become a committed rod-and-line angler, enjoying legal sea trout fishing on the Esk and spending countless winter nights pursuing cod from the Yorkshire coast. One day I bumped into Jack, probably in one of Whitby’s pubs, and inevitably the conversation turned to fishing. He was interested in my cod fishing and particularly keen to learn how to catch fish from the shore. We agreed that we ought to go out together one evening.
Then Jack made a rather surprising announcement. After years of poaching, bailiffs and brushes with the law, he’d finally decided to go legal, just like me. He had bought himself a migratory fish rod licence and was apparently enjoying the pleasures of legitimate angling. I was delighted to hear it and naturally asked whereabouts he’d been fishing.
He mentioned a particular stretch of the Esk, one I knew was privately controlled and certainly not somewhere ordinary working-class lads like us could simply turn up and cast a line. It was the sort of place where the fishing was reserved for those fortunate enough to have the appropriate permission, something neither of us was likely to enjoy. The private fishing signs made that perfectly clear.
“Hang on, Jack,” I said. “That’s private fishing. You can’t fish there.”
He looked at me as though I was worrying about absolutely nothing.
“I know,” he replied. “I just pulled the private sign up and threw it in the river.”
And that was Jack.
After a lifetime of poaching, he’d finally bought the licence, acquired the rod and decided to embrace the legal side of fishing. Unfortunately, nobody had quite managed to explain to him that obeying the rules involved rather more than removing the ones he didn’t particularly like.
He’d gone legal, all right. Just not quite as legal as the rest of us.